I went to a student experience panel about a month ago at a university here in Toronto. It was part of an Xppression Against Oppression week the university's student union was holding and there were several students and faculty members on the panel who spoke about their summer experiences volunteering or working overseas and in "Third World" countries. Not many students attended since it was held during the midterm period, and those who did appeared to be genuinely interested in the topics and wanted to know how they would be able to obtain internships, work, or volunteer positions abroad. One panelist had gone to a west African country, I forgot which, and described his experience volunteering at an orphanage. He told quite a story, "no electricity!", "everybody speaks English!", "poverty!", "bathrooms are holes in the ground!", "sleep on the floor!", "corruption, violence!". I've never been to this west African country, but he's probably telling the truth, and people need to be told of what goes on beyond their safe university campus (unless you're at UCLA or York, then UNsafe campuses).
I go to a lot of political events, many of which have a socialist, anti-imperialist, anti-capitalist theme, even borderline Marxist. There is a lot of talk about the power of the labour force, grassroots efforts, and armed resistance. I support armed resistance. Under the right circumstances, armed resistance is the means by which many who have been oppressed and occupied have been able to regain their freedom. And, let's face it, it makes no sense to be civilly disobedient when you've been shot at with M16s and F16s for the past 60 years. We sing a lot resistance songs at these events.
So clearly, I don't have a problem with the overall messages and purposes of the above. What I find though is a lot of the time, the messages get romanticized and lose their essence. It becomes glamourized, "help the less fortunate, yeah!", you get caught up in the "foreigness" and "otherness" of the experience.
In the case of the student speaking of his totally "African" experience, it was tough, but cool and exciting to have to light up candles at night to be able to see. It was nice to go back to a proper porcelain toilet, 'cause people back there had to go in the BUSH. Yes, it's different, it's harsh, but it is what it is. We don't need to turn it into a freak show. Give it the proper respect and attention for what it IS, not for how it compares with what it ISN'T.
In the case of the politcal events, the meaning of resistance often becomes skewed, "you gotta fight the MAN". You get caught up in the "ra-ra!" songs and the rhetoric, and the feeling of being "revolutionaries" and fighting for the oppressed. Why are you a socialist? Why do you support armed resistance? People become more attached to the hype and the romanticized image of becoming a freedom fighter or a "lefty", rather than the actual struggle and actions. I'm probably guilty of it as well, but we all need a reminder to ground ourselves and reflect back to the real reasons behind our actions and political support.
If it's an important message that needs to be spread, you won't need to add glamour or spice it up to give it attention. Just let it be...
Recent Comments
Cirus, thank yo
<